Conservatory Or Extension – Which Is Best For You?

conservatory vs extension

Both a conservatory and an extension are meant to be expansions to your living space, yet both have a different impact on your home due to their unique structure and uses. The many considerations that go into the choice include:

  • Natural light – Conservatories allow large amounts of natural light into the building via a predominately glass roof and walls.
  • Thermally efficient – Glass is a worse insulating material than solid stone, meaning it retains less heat overall, possibly causing more wasted energy over the long run and being less comfortable.
  • Cost – The lowered initial cost is partly what makes conservatories so compelling, attractive design aside. Extensions require more complex construction, which commands a higher price.
  • Planning Permission – Conservatories often fall under permitted development rights, unlike extensions which usually require planning permission from a local authority.
  • Building regulations approval – Conservatories typically follow less strict building regulations compared to extensions, provided a certain condition is met.
  • Aesthetic appeal – A house extension presents itself seamlessly, whereas a conservatory is so different design-wise that it stands out as an add-on.
  • Functionality – Both a conservatory and an extension serve very different functions, one being a place to relax, whilst the other has versatility (bedroom, kitchen etc)
  • Long-term value – Both offer great long-term value, with extensions typically being evaluated higher.

 

In this article, we will go over these differences in larger detail, ensuring that you can make an informed decision and not be blindsided by unexpected legislation, compatibility issues and costs when it comes to conservatory installation.

The Role Of Natural Light In A Conservatory/Extension

When thinking of conservatories, natural light is the main element that immediately comes to mind, given that it’s its predominant feature. If an environment where both the indoors and the outdoors are blended to this degree is what you’re looking for, conservatories may be the choice for you. That being said – this doesn’t mean extensions are completely out as an option.

Conservatories

Starting in the 18th century, conservatories were originally more akin to a garden room, designed to house delicate, exotic flora (such as citrus trees), which required a flood of light to properly grow. As this practice went out of fashion, conservatories then became a place of small social gatherings, taking advantage of the indoor environment and the seamless outdoor light.

The predominance of glass also allows for an unobstructed view of the garden and/or surrounding landscape, effectively becoming an outing without having to deal with any potentially oppressive outdoor elements.

Extensions

Extensions are made up predominantly of solid walls, as are most of the rooms in the average residential house. Less natural light enters the space as a result – though this can be offset through the placement of windows, skylights or even glass doors. Typically, people install extensions for specific purposes, such as home offices etc, meaning they want a more balanced light approach.

That being said, extensions have the advantage of having more wiring – meaning that light can be controlled by more advanced electronics. Whether this be via artificial lighting, or through specialised motorised blinds.

Are Conservatories As Thermally Efficient As An Extension?

Glass isn’t the best insulation material, with extra steps coming mostly in the form of glazing to offset this trait. This adds a lot of cost to your overall bill for a conservatory, which should lead you to consider whether or not you truly want to invest.

Conservatory

Failing to properly insulate your conservatory leads to temperature fluctuations. This means that in summer, the glass could magnify the heat and cause serious overheating, whereas in winter, the conservatory may be far too cold to use. This, to many, is a flaw that can’t be easily ignored.

Whereas glazing is the main way to combat this, adding additional systems like an insulated tiled roof, underfloor heating or air conditioning can also help you properly regulate the temperature.

Extension

Extensions are constructed with the same types of walls as your main house, meaning insulated walls, a solid roof etc. These features make the extension just as capable of insulating your home as the rest, ensuring you keep a comfortable temperature for your new room. This is due to building regulations mandating certain energy efficiency standards, especially for new spaces.

What Is The Difference Between Conservatory And Extension Costs?

There is a considerable gulf between conservatory costs and what is charged for an extension. This is down to the complexity of the construction of each structure.

Conservatory

Conservatories are cheaper than extensions, both initially and in the long run. The initial cost is fairly high, ranging from between £8,000 to £20,000 in the UK. Not only this, but a conservatory typically takes between 2 and 4 weeks to complete – highlighting the much simpler construction job that it is versus an extension.

That being said, a conservatory has higher running costs than an extension. You can expect your conservatory to be at least 20% less energy-efficient as a result – which could result in around £200 – £500 extra in energy bills annually. For those seeking year-round use, as well as a stable temperature environment, consider paying for a more premium construction or adding additional heating/cooling systems.

Extensions

House extensions are on a different scale from conservatories when it comes to both cost and length of time to complete. In the UK, you’re looking at between £20,000 and £40,000 for a single-storey extension, or £50,000 to £80,000 for a two-storey extension. The cost of each square meter can vary between £1,200 and £2,000.

There is a return of sorts on this intense expenditure, however. Extensions provide long-term and substantial value to a property, with the Nationwide Building Society finding that a well-executed extension can increase property value by up to 20-30%. Conservatories typically don’t add anywhere near as much value, if any.

Do You Need Planning Permission For A Conservatory/Extension?

Planning permission is a stamp of approval by your local authority that your proposed development can go ahead as outlined. It’s common knowledge that it doesn’t always apply to conservatories or extensions. In these cases, they fall under permitted development rights.

Permitted Development

The following table outlines the permitted development rules for both conservatories and extensions:

Criteria Conservatory Single-Storey Extension Two-Storey Extension
Max Height 4 metres 4 metres Must not exceed the height of the existing house
Rear Extension Length Max 3 metres (attached) or 4 metres (detached) Max 3 metres (attached) or 4 metres (detached) Max 3 metres from the rear wall
Forward of Principal Elevation Not Permitted Not Permitted Not Permitted
Proximity to Boundary Max eaves height 3 metres if within 2 metres Max eaves height 3 metres if within 2 metres Must be at least 7 metres from the rear boundary
Garden Coverage Must not cover more than 50% of the garden Must not cover more than 50% of the garden Must not cover more than 50% of the garden
Planning Permission Generally not required Generally not required Usually required

 

Planning Permission

Planning approval hinges on meeting the following requirements for both builds:

Criteria Conservatory Single-Storey Extension Two-Storey Extension
Height Limit Exceeded If over 4 metres If over 4 metres If over the height of the existing house
Extension Beyond Rear Wall If more than 3 metres (attached) or 4 metres (detached) If more than 3 metres (attached) or 4 metres (detached) Always required if exceeding 3 metres from the rear wall
Forward of Principal Elevation Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission
Proximity to Boundary If eaves exceed 3 metres within 2 metres of the boundary If eaves exceed 3 metres within 2 metres of the boundary Always required if less than 7 metres from the rear boundary
Garden Coverage If covering more than 50% of the garden If covering more than 50% of the garden If covering more than 50% of the garden
Designated Areas Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission
Listed Buildings Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission Always requires planning permission

 

Does My Conservatory/Extension Require Building Regulations Approval?

Building regulations are a set of rules that ensure the following:

  • Structural integrity – The structure is stable and can withstand loads from the environment, such as wind, snow, occupancy etc.
  • Fire safety – Fire-resistant materials, safe escape routes and the installation of smoke alarms/detectors are paramount

 

Conservatory

Suppose you separate your conservatory from the main house by using an external-quality door. In that case, your conservatory is then subject to fewer building regulations than otherwise, meaning you don’t need to meet the same energy efficiency standards as the rest of the house. If you plan to make the conservatory extra living space indoors by removing the external door, stricter requirements for thermal insulation, energy efficiency and structural integrity apply.

Extension

Extensions are classed as being part of the main living space of your home and therefore must comply with all building regulations, which cover:

  • Structural Integrity – The foundations must be one metre deep or more, walls must have a minimum thickness of 215mm for brick and roof structures must withstand wind speeds of up to 56m/s.
  • Fire safety – The internal walls of your extension should be able to achieve at least 30 minutes of fire resistance, while external walls may require up to 60 minutes depending on how close they are to other buildings. They must also have clear, unobstructed escape routes with doors/corridors wide enough for evacuation, and smoke alarms on every level, interconnected and powered with battery backup.
  • Energy efficiency – The u-values of your walls should be no more than 0.18W/m²K for new builds, roof of 0.13 W/m²K, and floors 0.13 W/m²K. Windows and doors must achieve U-values of 1.4 W/m²K or lower, and boilers must be at least 92% efficient with programmable thermostats for temperature control.
  • Ventilation – Rooms must have windows that can open and provide ventilation equal to 1/20th of the floor area. Bathrooms and kitchens must have extractor fans capable of 15-30 litres per second to remove moisture and prevent condensation.
  • And more.

 

Conclusion

The choice between a conservatory and an extension is mainly one of use and, its biggest barrier, cost. If you want to add extra living space to your home in a cost-effective way, we recommend going with conservatories and saving thoughts of any extensions for when you need specialised rooms with a specific purpose in the future.

Table of Contents

Click For A Free Quote